Home About Services Work Blog FAQ Contact
Back to blog

Web Design 7 min read

A Boring Website Is Costing You Customers

Open five local contractor websites in a row. You will see a stock photo of a smiling man in a hard hat, a headline promising quality service you can trust, three icons in a row, and a testimonial slider that changes before you finish reading it. Swap the logos and you could not tell which business was which.

That is what I mean by boring. A site can be plain and quiet and still be good. Boring means interchangeable, and an interchangeable website has a specific cost: the visitor has no reason to pick you over the next tab.

Why is my website not getting customers?

If the site loads, works on a phone and the contact form delivers, the most common reason is that nothing on it gives a visitor a reason to choose you. When your site reads like every competitor's, people decide in seconds that they have seen enough, and they leave without calling anyone in particular. Being findable gets them there. Being specific is what makes them stay.

Rule out the mechanical problems first. A slow site, a phone layout that breaks, or a form that never sends will sink any design. I laid out a quick way to check all of that in how to audit your own website in 20 minutes. If those pass and the phone still is not ringing, keep reading.

How fast do visitors decide?

Faster than most owners assume. A 2006 study by researchers at Carleton University in Ottawa, published as "Attention web designers: You have 50 milliseconds to make a good first impression!", found that people form a judgment about a page's visual appeal within 50 milliseconds. That is before they have read a word.

Reading comes next, and it does not buy you much more time. The Nielsen Norman Group, summarizing a Microsoft Research analysis of more than two billion page visits, reported in 2011 that users often leave pages within 10 to 20 seconds, and that to earn several minutes of attention you have to make your value clear within the first 10.

First impressions also bleed into everything after. NN/g describes the aesthetic-usability effect, first documented in a 1995 study: people perceive attractive designs as easier to use, even when they are not. A site that looks cared for gets the benefit of the doubt. A site that looks like a default gets none.

Is a template the problem?

No. Sameness is the problem, and templates just make it easy. I went through when a template is the right call in custom website vs. template, and plenty of businesses are well served by one. A template filled with your own photos, your own words and your own prices can be far from boring. A custom build filled with stock photos and "we are committed to excellence" is boring at a higher price.

The test I use is simple. Cover your logo and your business name. Read the home page. Could this be your competitor's site, or a business in the same trade in Kingston or Sudbury? If the answer is yes, the design is not really the problem. The content is.

What makes a small business website worth staying on?

Specifics, mostly. The things only you can put on the page.

  • Real photos. Your shop, your crew, your finished work, your actual storefront on your actual street. Stock photos are easy to spot, and they tell a visitor nothing about you.
  • Plain, specific words. What you do, for whom, and where. "Kitchen and bathroom renovations in Arnprior, Renfrew and the west end of Ottawa" does more work than "quality renovations for your home."
  • Numbers where you can give them. Price ranges, typical timelines, how long you have been at it, how many jobs a year. Even a range tells a visitor whether to keep reading.
  • Proof with names attached. A real project, in a real town, with a photo and a sentence about what the customer needed. One of those beats a carousel of unattributed five-star quotes.
  • A point of view. What you will not do, what you recommend, and why. Opinions are what make a business sound like people rather than a brochure.
  • One obvious next step. Call, book, or request a quote. Not five buttons competing for attention.

None of this is design in the visual sense, and most of it costs nothing but time. It is also what the best-looking sites have in common. The design is there to carry specific content, not to replace it.

Gimmicks that do not help

When owners feel their site is dull, the instinct is to add movement. A rotating banner. A pop-up. Things that slide in as you scroll. Most of these make a site feel busier, not better.

Auto-rotating sliders are the clearest case. Jakob Nielsen wrote in his 2013 piece on auto-forwarding carousels that new panels should appear only when users ask for them, and gave the example of a test user who missed a prominent discount because the slide changed before it could be read. Movement people did not ask for gets treated like advertising and ignored.

Every one of these also has a cost in weight and speed, which I covered in why your website speed matters. A slider that nobody reads, slowing down a page people are leaving anyway, is the worst of both.

Motion that earns its place

I am not against animation. I use it. The rule I work to is that motion has to show the visitor something they want to see, or respond to something they did. A before-and-after slider that the visitor drags on a renovation site. A menu that opens smoothly instead of jumping. A product you can turn around to look at.

On the Brauwerk Hoffman rebuild, the home page has a beer can you can spin in 3D. That is not decoration. The cans are the product, and turning one over to read the label is what you would do in the shop. It also falls back to a still image when a browser cannot run it, so nobody is punished for having an older phone. That is the test: if the motion disappeared, would the visitor lose information or only lose the show?

Good motion also respects people who have asked their device to reduce motion. That setting exists for a reason, and a well-built site honours it.

Where to start

Rewrite the first screen of your home page. In ten seconds, a stranger should know what you do, where you do it, who it is for, and what to do next. Then replace your three most visible stock photos with real ones, even if they are taken on a phone on a good day. Those two changes alone move most small business sites from interchangeable to yours.

If you have done that and the site still feels like it could belong to anyone, let's talk. I will tell you what is making it blend in, and whether it needs new words, new photos or a new build.

Frequently asked questions

Why is my website not getting customers?

If the site is fast, works on a phone and its contact form delivers, the usual reason is that it gives visitors no reason to choose you. A site that reads like every competitor's, with stock photos and generic promises, gets judged in seconds and closed. Specific words, real photos, prices or ranges, and named examples of your work are what make people stay and call.

How long do visitors spend deciding about a website?

Very little. A 2006 Carleton University study found people judge a page's visual appeal within 50 milliseconds. The Nielsen Norman Group, drawing on Microsoft Research data, reported in 2011 that users often leave a page within 10 to 20 seconds, and that a site has to make its value clear within about 10 seconds to hold attention longer.

Does a website template make my business look generic?

Not by itself. Sameness comes from content more than code. A template filled with your own photos, words and prices can stand out, while a custom site full of stock images and generic claims will not. Cover your logo and read your home page: if it could belong to a competitor, the content needs work before the design does.

Do animations and sliders make a website more engaging?

Usually not. Auto-rotating sliders and pop-ups tend to be ignored like advertising and slow the page down. Motion helps when it shows visitors something they came to see or responds to what they do, like a before-and-after slider they drag or a product they can turn. It should also respect the reduce-motion setting on the visitor's device.

About the author

Rob Kingsbury

Rob Kingsbury is the founder of Kingsbury Creative and a Professor at Algonquin College. He has been building websites since the mid-1990s, and has spent the last decade focused on small businesses across Renfrew County and the Ottawa Valley.

Let's build
yours next.

Tell us about your business and we'll talk through what it needs.

Start Your Project